Noise

I’m a bit hesitant to write this post because it touches on a controversial subject. But now that I’ve typed that it probably makes you all the more eager to read this post right? We all love a good controversy :)

This is something that has been weighing on me for awhile. It has to do with the blogging/internet phenomenon that has quickly enveloped and defined our culture. As a 90′s kid, I remember my first encounters with the internet in the form of online chatting. E-mail became a big deal when I was in high school. Blogs first appeared when I was in college.

Back then blogs were mostly personal journals. Mine still is and always will be. My blog is nothing more than a way to update my family and friends (and I guess share an occasional thought about something). It doesn’t consume very much of my time and I don’t write on it very often. I don’t try to promote it either because I don’t really care about numbers, but I also leave it public in case an occasional former acquaintance stumbles upon it and is interested in what we’re doing.

But we all know that blogging is much more than that now. People make money off of their blogs. We all have certain bloggers we enjoy following and even look to for advice. This is especially true in the reformed Baptist world. Every big gun out there has a blog and is constantly analyzing the world through a Christian lens.

These are mostly encouraging. I say mostly because sometimes their unsolicited opinions on many hotbed issues tend to seep through. I guess that is what a blog is for (you are getting my unsolicited opinion right now). But the problem is that these opinions often come from places of authority and, dare I say it, an ivory tower perspective.

For example, I recently stumbled upon an article about gender roles by a relatively well-known seminarian. I believe in gender roles–God created men and women differently with different gifts and purposes to fulfill. However, I think we can all agree that the application of this to every specific situation in our lives may not look exactly the same for every person and every family. If you don’t agree with that please let me know in the comment section.

The author of this article didn’t mince words. He wrote all about men as sole providers, women as sole homemakers, the evils of daycare and delaying God’s ‘good gift of children.’ He used his own family as an example: how he works hard all day, comes home to a delicious meal, a spotless home and two beautiful children…and this is God’s perfect plan. All that’s missing is the dog. He and his wife look at the kids playing at the daycare across street and feel sorry for them because their lives aren’t nearly as perfect. Nice. I’m sure the mom’s of those kids would appreciate hearing his views on their sub-par parenting. Too bad they’re probably way too busy making a living to read his blog. Not everyone makes money reading and writing in a bubble.

You can sense my sarcasm and I don’t intend for it to be directed towards spotless homes, delicious meals, or beautiful kids. However, the tone of this article was very condescending and left me feeling completely condemned.

All I could think about was how Jared has to make dinner on the nights that I work. How we’ve been married for three years and we don’t have kids yet. How I’m not making homemade bread all the time or sewing curtains or plucking organic veggies from our home garden.  I was practically in tears when Jared came home because I felt like a failure.

When I told Jared about the article his response was simple, ‘I bet that guy and his wife are glad there are nurses to take care of them and their kids when they get sick.’

He has a way with words.

Then I realized, who in the h-e-double hockeysticks  world does this guy think he is? He doesn’t know anything about my life or the decisions we’ve made as far as work, kids, who takes the trash out, etc. Am I not honoring my husband? He is happy with me as a wife and doesn’t feel the least bit slighted by anything I do. And my job is to take care of sick people. Why should I feel bad about that? And when we do have kids, will we not do what is best for our family? And that might include me working or not working for awhile, I don’t know, but I do know it won’t involve looking across the street in a patronizing manner and judging what other people do.

My point is not really to debate gender roles at all, or even the specific applications, but to address the impact that blogs and the internet can have on our lives. I’ve talked with many women recently (some who do stay home and make bread with their beautiful children) who feel equally condemned because they are not crafty enough, organized enough, or talented enough to compete with what other women are doing in the blogosphere.

I even felt like I had to apologize to Jared the other night because I used alfredo sauce from the jar instead of making it from scratch.

And that is ridiculous.

Jared is helpful in walking through passages in Scripture with me that outline what it means to be a godly woman. These are always convicting, but never condemning. There are definite areas I need to grow in, but I never walk away from these passages feeling like I need to make more crafts, or that my job or lack of children right now is sinful. This is the life God has given me and my job provides the perfect opportunity to demonstrate the graceful and nurturing spirit that I’ve been given as woman. (You don’t have to point out that this post might not be the most graceful and nurturing thing I’ve written–I get that :) ).

So, yes, it’s helpful to read blogs but they are not the infallible word of God. In fact, sometimes they can be little more than the noise of a clanging cymbal. Let’s turn to Scripture and our own local body of believers, those who know us well, for our primary source of encouragement and admonishment.

*I do apologize if this blog came across as a clanging cymbal to anyone reading this. It was not meant to be instructional about the application of gender roles in any form or fashion*

Advertisement
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to Noise

  1. suz says:

    beautifully written…no clanging. the thing that always seems to be forgotten in discussions of roles is the role of love. my mom has never fit into a typical gender role…she works, manages the finances of the house, wears pants (and looks fantastic), sent me to daycare. but none of that has ever left me questioning her as a wife or as a mother because she loves her husband and children better than anyone i have ever known. she isn’t a good example of what many churches would tout as a “godly wife and mother”, but she is a GREAT example of christ.

    • juliejames says:

      linda does look fantastic in her pants! no, i agree–i think most parents would prefer not to use daycare but some families have little choice if they are going to pay their bills and we should be encouraging to those who are trying to love their children well by providing financial stability, not condemning. you learned a lot of valuable things through the actions of your mother, and i too, have been encouraged by the selflessness of linda!

  2. Emily says:

    I think part of the blog problem is that many people don’t show transparency. They never show their house looking like a mess, or discuss the takeout they eat the 6 nights a week they are not baking up the best meal right before taking a professional level artistic picture of it, or blog about the big fight they had with their husband that morning (okay, maybe that’s a good idea to leave off the internet…:) but you know what I mean. This is a great point you have made! It’s so easy to be smug when we’re only showing the pretty side of our life.

    • juliejames says:

      yeah, i’ve heard a lot of discussions recently about that. and i guess it’s true. my blog isn’t always the most transparent and, really, who wants to read about the uglier side of life anyway?

      still, i think you make a really good point. there are some things that are wise to leave off the internet (probably 99.9% of what happens in my daily life is best not blogged about :) ), but the fact that so many people have shared with me that blogs/facebook often play a role in their discontentment and discouragement with their lives has got to mean something. not necessarily that the blogger is wrong to share, but that we are allowing other humans to lay out standards for us when 1) they don’t know us, 2) we don’t know them, 3) if we do know them like you said, we are only seeing ‘their best,’ 4) God has given us his word and the local body of believers to instruct us on how to live and we don’t really need cyberworld to tell us what to do. I know the internet is a huge blessing, but it’s influence has really gotten out of control.

  3. Dad says:

    All I can say honey is “go fix me a sandwich” !! :)

    Love Dad

    • juliejames says:

      anything for you, dad! i’ll be sure to tell you all about my day cleaning abdominal wounds and dumping ostomies while you eat it too :)

  4. Laura Hug says:

    Thank you for this Julie, I love your thoughts on it all. I was just having a discussion with some friends on this topic this weekend, and I have tended to be pretty critical on this issue. But I’ve realized how different this looks in different contexts, seasons of life, personalities, families, etc, and how to be more gracious and open to different opinions or views on that. I think there should be a healthy balance, that I don’t often see on this issue. It’s frustrating when people go to extremes on either end of this. I especially feel condemned as a single woman, as if I am not a full human or really a godly woman because I am not married and don’t have children, and I’m in my late twenties. And I don’t know if I will ever have that opportunity, as much as I would love to. But I don’t believe that makes me less useful to God. However even, and sometimes especially, our Christian culture acts like being a wife and mother is the absolute highest calling on earth, and there is something wrong with me because I am not in that situation. But really we’re called to follow Jesus and He gifts us in different ways and places us in different situations and locations to know Him deeply and share His love wherever we are, that identity shouldn’t change no matter our location or relationships. If any of that makes sense!

    • juliejames says:

      laura, thank you for your thoughts as well. i have heard many single friends share similar feelings and i remember having them as well before i was married. and honestly, it seems like people are never happy with where you are in life. single people should be married. married people should have children. and now, even the number of children people have is subject to judgment.

      i think a lot of what’s out there is a needed response to a culture that doesn’t rightly value marriage, children, and family…all wonderful things God has created for His glory. but i’m starting to believing that the bat has been so far swung in the other direction that some women (and maybe men too) start to feel alienated and perhaps even guilty when they shouldn’t.

      as i mentioned in my post, we’re not really sure what we’ll do in future when it comes to the size of our family, jobs, childcare, etc. but i know that my job and my life right now is not just a consolation prize or a temporary lesser ideal so i can get to my true calling. it’s part of my life, part of my sphere of influence, and part of my ministry to other people. i definitely think it is secondary to my family, but it also helps my family a great deal right now. whether the benefits will outweigh the costs in the future is yet to be determined :)

      and i don’t think i’m rebelling against the created order because i work outside my home and my husband has to help out around the house more than maybe some other husbands do…especially when he is more than happy to do so. he was raised in home where he had to do chores. that’s why this particular article rubbed me the wrong way. i also think it’s poor taste to condemn women who use daycare or other forms of childcare when you don’t know the reasons behind that decision. my mom was a working mother and she did a fantastic job.

      i should of have just written another post, but overall, i know this is a hotbed issue right now, and while my perspective tends to be a little more centrist than some, i do agree with most of what is out there about gender roles. i just think there is more biblical freedom in specific applications than some realize. and maybe i’ll share more about that in a later post!

  5. Jared says:

    I believe I’ve been slightly misquoted. What I said was “I bet this guy wouldn’t say this to his wife’s gynecologist.” Not trying to be crude, just trying to make a point.

  6. Veronique says:

    Julie, thank you for being transparent and sharing your heart! I have said this before and I say it again…you are a woman who loves the Lord and seem to always be striving hard after Him. This is what is most important, more than your domestic skills, ability to make every single food from scratch and how many kids you end up having/not having. May you be encouraged to keep making Jesus the greatest Treasure of all in your home, your marriage and in the workplace. Love you, girl!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s